Opinion

Sports

Updated

College Sports Is a Business Now, So Run It Like One

The money is already here, and what is missing is the structure every other sports business has: contracts, a cap, transfer limits and one eligibility rule for everyone.

College sports is a business now, and it needs to be treated like one. The schools are already paying players directly, the courts are already deciding who gets to play, and investors are already at the table, so the only thing still missing is the structure that every other sports business has.

The money arrived before the rules did

When NIL was made, as I understood it, it was supposed to be so players could profit off their name, image and likeness and do endorsement deals. What we have now is something much bigger than endorsements. Under the settlement, each school could share up to $20.5 million with its athletes in the first year, 2025-26, and that cap is expected to rise about 4% a year, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures.

I have no problem with players being paid, because they are the reason anyone watches. My problem is that the pay showed up without the things that normally come with it, which are a real contract, a cap that everyone understands, limits on how often a player can leave, and one set of eligibility rules that applies the same way at every school.

Eligibility should not depend on where you sue

The eligibility decisions this fall are the clearest example, because they came from different places and landed in different spots, and it all looks very arbitrary.

At LSU, Bleacher Report relayed an Oct. 20 report from CBS Sports reporter Matt Norlander that the SEC will not clear RJ Luis Jr. for this season, because the conference bars a return to college after a player signs a professional contract. The article says Luis signed a two-way contract with the Boston Celtics and later an Exhibit 10 contract. He never played in an NBA game that counted: the Fox Sports game log lists only three preseason games for Boston in October 2025, and Hoops Rumors reported that the Celtics waived him from the two-way deal on Oct. 15, re-signed him on the Exhibit 10 deal and planned to send him to their G League team in Maine. The article also says he had already won a preliminary injunction in his own suit against the NCAA, and that the SEC announced its rule the next day, so a judge said one thing and a conference rule said another. It did not end there. After a court order on Nov. 13 that barred the SEC and NCAA from penalizing LSU for rostering him, Luis played on Nov. 18 and had 11 points and 9 rebounds in a 79-67 win over UL Monroe, according to Yahoo Sports.

Robbie Avila played in the NBA Summer League for the Lakers. On Nov. 5 a circuit judge in St. Louis granted him a preliminary injunction to play a fifth season, according to an Associated Press report, which also says he never signed a pro contract. A week later Sports Illustrated reported that the College Sports Commission found no roster slot for him at Saint Louis, which already had 15 players, and that he was expected to enroll at TCU instead.

Those two cases are not identical, and the signed contract is a real difference. What bothers me is how each answer was reached. A judge cleared one player, a conference rule announced the next day blocked him, a second court order put him on the floor, while a state court cleared the other and a roster limit sent him to a different school. From what I saw, LSU took the brunt of the criticism, and hardly anyone said a word about the second case. A business that takes itself seriously has one rulebook, written down in advance, so that a player, a coach and a fan can all know the answer before the season starts instead of after a hearing.

What structure looks like

The fix, in my view, is contracts, structure, transfer limits and a lot more rules.

A contract tells both sides what they owe each other and for how long, which is the plain reason every major professional league uses one. A salary cap keeps the richest programs from simply outbidding everyone else, and the NBA's cap shows how a league builds a whole system around that one number. Transfer limits let a team plan a roster for more than a few months at a time.

Some of this is already on paper. On Oct. 7 the NCAA's Division I Cabinet approved a 10-day football transfer window beginning the first business day after Jan. 1, and we explain it in our transfer portal page. An executive order signed on April 3 encourages one immediate transfer, a second after a degree, and a five-year limit on eligibility, according to a Morgan Lewis summary, which also notes that the order calls on the governing body to change its rules rather than changing them itself.

Congress is closer than it has been. The Senate passed the Protect College Sports Act by a vote of 77 to 22, the committee announced Sept. 28, and on Nov. 18 schools and athletes backing it were still urging the House to vote, according to the Senate Commerce Committee. When the bill was unveiled in May, ESPN reported that it would limit players to one transfer without penalty and to five years of eligibility, and would give the NCAA legal cover to enforce the spending cap the NCAA and its major conferences had already agreed to, slightly more than $20 million per school each year.

The bill stops short on the question I care about most. The committee's own release describes it as neutral on whether athletes are employees, and ESPN reported that the bill does not address the question while the NCAA has asked Congress to bar athletes from being employees. I do not think a business can stay neutral on that for long, because you cannot have enforceable contracts and a cap that holds up without deciding what the players are.

Outside money, and the NFL

Investors already see a business here. The Big Ten weighed an equity deal of more than $2 billion, as CBS Sports reported, before ESPN reported that opposition from Michigan and USC paused it. The Big 12's board approved a five-year deal with RedBird Capital Partners that offers each school up to $30 million, with no equity for RedBird, according to Front Office Sports.

I would go a step further and say the NFL buying into or putting money into college football could help too. This is my idea, not something I am reporting. The reason it appeals to me is practical: the NFL depends on college football to develop its players, and it already knows how to run a sport with contracts and a cap.

What I would ask for

  1. A written contract for every paid player, with a set length.
  2. A cap that every school and every fan can look up.
  3. A limit on transfers that holds in every sport.
  4. One eligibility rule that is applied the same way at every school.

This is an opinion column. It argues a position and is not a news report.

Have another question?