SportsNFL

Explainer

Updated

How do NFL tiebreakers work?

Key facts

Wild card ties between clubs from different divisions skip the division record step, and common games count there only with a minimum of four.

When two NFL clubs in the same division finish with the same record, the league's tiebreaking procedures compare their head-to-head record first, then their record in division games, in common games and in conference games, and go on step by step until one club is ahead, with a coin toss as the last step. The same procedures decide postseason playoff spots and are also used to set regular-season schedules, and the league applies them at the end of the regular season.

Records are compared as won-lost-tied percentages, and the league's page notes that "Tie games count as one-half win and one-half loss for both clubs." (NFL)

The steps in order

The division list applies to clubs in the same division. The wild card list applies when clubs from different divisions tie for one of the three wild card spots in each conference; when tied wild card clubs are from the same division, the division list is used. The table puts both two-club lists side by side, with the step number each one uses on the NFL's page.

TiebreakerDivision stepWild card step
Head-to-head record11, if applicable
Record in division games2Not used
Record in common games33, minimum of four games
Record in conference games42
Strength of victory, all games54
Strength of schedule, all games65
Combined rank in points scored and allowed among conference teams76
Combined rank in points scored and allowed among all teams87
Net points in common games9Not used
Net points in conference gamesNot used8
Net points in all games109
Net touchdowns in all games1110
Coin toss1211

A wild card tie skips the division record entirely and moves the conference record ahead of common games, and it counts common games only when there are at least four of them, according to the league's procedures.

When three or more clubs are tied

For a three-way or larger tie inside a division, the NFL's page lists the same 12 steps, with head-to-head meaning the record in games among all the tied clubs.

A three-way or larger wild card tie works differently, under the same page:

  • The division tiebreaker is applied first, so only the highest ranked club from each division stays in the comparison.
  • The next step is a head-to-head sweep, which counts only when one club beat each of the others or lost to each of the others.
  • The rest of the list follows the two-club wild card order, from conference record down to the coin toss.
  • After the first wild card club is named, the whole procedure is repeated for the second and third spots.

Restarts and other edge cases

The league's procedures set these rules for what happens partway through a tiebreak:

  • Only one club advances in any step. The clubs still tied go back to the first step of the division or wild card list that applies.
  • If a three-club tie is cut to two clubs at any step, the two go back to step 1 of the two-club list.
  • If a four-club tie is cut to three, the three restart at step 1 of the three-club list in a division tie, and at step 2 of the three-club list in a wild card tie.
  • Records against common opponents are compared by won-lost-tied percentage, because tied teams may have played those opponents a different number of times.

How the points ranking step works

The combined ranking step adds a team's rank in points scored to its rank in points allowed, and the lowest total wins. In the NFL's own example, a team that is first in points scored and second in points allowed has a combined ranking of 3, and it beats a team that is third in points scored and first in points allowed, whose combined ranking is 4. Teams tied for a position each get that rank, so two teams tied for first in points scored are both ranked 1, and the next team is still ranked 3.

Home field among playoff teams

The same lists also set home-field priority, under the league's procedures. Among division winners, the wild card tiebreakers apply. Among wild card qualifiers, the division tiebreakers apply when the teams are from the same division, and the wild card tiebreakers apply when they are not.

Ties in the draft order

Draft order uses a different first step. Teams with identical records are separated by strength of schedule, which the NFL's draft rules page describes as the combined winning percentage of a team's opponents, and the team that faced the schedule with the lowest winning percentage picks earlier.

If that is still tied, the division or conference tiebreakers apply. For two teams from different conferences, the tiebreaking page and the draft rules page list the same order: head-to-head, record in common games with a minimum of four, strength of victory, combined ranking among all teams in points scored and allowed, net points in all games, net touchdowns in all games and a coin toss.

Clubs tied for a draft position do not keep the same order all the way through. Under the NFL's procedures, two clubs that were tied swap positions from round to round, and in a tie of three or more, the club at the top of the tied group moves to the bottom in the next round while the others move up one place.

This week's games are on the NFL schedule page.

Have another question?